Like many photographers, I aspire to make better images and an
important part of that process is the camera and
lens equipment.
I have always been interested in Medium Format photography but to date
the cost of the camera/lens digital systems remains very steep and out with my
budget.
I have always admired the work of the British landscape
photographer,
Joe Cornishwho uses Phase One medium format kit, so I decided to explore the
ongoing development of Phase One.
Phase One is
pretty much one of the the market leaders in Medium Format camera and
digital backs and I guess the ideal company to use as a 'barometer' in
setting a MF standard to relate to.
Coming from a DSLR background and trying to understand Medium Format
camera and the lens technology was difficult but rewarding. As usual, I
write everything down for future reference and ongoing development,
hence this article.
It is
interesting that camera manufacturers and those review sites who favour
particular manufacturers always seem to avoid highlighting the
'wrinkles' with the technology which makes an analysis of the equipment
in relation to it's actual use in the 'field' quite difficult.
The Phase One System in 'organic terms' is a medium format
camera with the film back technology replaced by a box
shaped digital back complete with digital sensor, screen and menu
controls clipped onto the rear of the camera. The camera and back uses
interchangeable manual/autofocus medium format lenses. The latest Phase
One digital backs, the IQ range, have touch screen and live view technology
and are designed to operate in 645 medium format.
Phase One -
Sensor Size
in relation to
Medium
Format
Medium format
FILM is shot in a variety of
aspect ratios,
which differ depending on the camera or frame insert used. The
most common aspect ratios are 6×6 (square/1:0 - 56mm x 56mm)
and 6×4.5 (rectangular/4:3 - 56mm x 45mm). Although 6x7 (56mm x
69mm) is also available as shown in the following video below.
The 6x6 or 6x7 names originate from film where the film is
actually 6cm x 6cm and 6cm x 7cm respectively but loses
millimeters due to the film sprockets at the top and bottom and
the gaps in-between the frames on the film.
The 6×4.5 format is usually referred to as "645", with
many cameras that use this ratio bearing "645" in their product
name. Cameras that can switch to different aspect ratios do so
by either switching camera backs, by using a frame insert, or by
use of special multi-format backs.
I did check out one of the latest Medium Format FILM
cameras to emerge, the Voigtlander Bessa III Wide and its
counter part the Fuji 670W (same camera) and this short video
provides a good idea of what a Medium Format FILM camera
is delivering -
The Voigtlander Bessa III Wide uses the
Film
format: 6 x 7 and 6 x 6 by selector switch, 6 x 7 size: 56 x
69mm, 6 x 6 size: 56 x 56mm. The Film used: 120 or 220 roll film
with Frames: 6 x 7 size: 120 – 10 shots, 220 – 20 shots. 6 x 6
size: 120 – 12 shots 220 – 24 shots. It has a fixed lens: HELIAR
3,5/80mm, 6 elements in 4 groups, Angle of view: 6 x 7 size =
57°, Angle of view: 6 x 6 size = 53°.
The 645
DIGITAL format "full frame" is now recognised as 56mm x 41.5mm in size. The latest Phase One
645DF camera body with the clip on IQ180 digital back with 16bit
80MPixel sensor is actually 53.7 x 40.4mm in size, not quite the 645
digital format.
For a comparison, the 35mm DSLR 'Full Frame' digital sensor is 36 x 24mm
in size.
Phase P 30+ Digital
Back Sensor
31 Mega Pixels
1.3
CCD Sensor Size - 44.2 x 33.1mm
Phase P 45+ Digital
Back Sensor
39 Mega Pixels
1.1
CCD Sensor Size - 49.1 x 36.8mm
Phase P 65+ Digital
Back Sensor
60 Mega Pixels
1.0
CCD Sensor Size - 53.9 x 40.4mm
Phase IQ 140
Digital Back Sensor
40 Mega Pixels
1.3
CCD Sensor Size - 43.9 x 32.9mm
Phase IQ 160
Digital Back Sensor
60 Mega Pixels
1.0
CCD Sensor Size - 53.9 x 40.4mm
Phase IQ 180
Digital Back Sensor
80 Mega Pixels
1.0
CCD Sensor Size - 53.7 x 40.4mm
Phase One - The IQ180 Sensor in Relation to 35mm Format
(also see my
diagram)
I am not a technical person but it appears that when a camera lens takes
in a scene, the image of light travels right through the centre of it
and is projected as a cone of light (circular) back towards the film or
sensor plane. The manufacturer places his film or sensor plane at a set
distance behind that lens in the light cones diameter which if the 4
edges touch the diameter of the circle it makes the film/sensor plane a
square and not a rectangle. At that point the film or sensor plane sees
the image as square but a manufacturer then crops, during manufacture/or
by using a camera frame inset, the vertical sides of the film or sensor
plane and moves the plane up into the middle of the (square) circle cone
of light. This has the effect of creating a rectangular image, usually
in an aspect ratio of 4:3 (nearly square) or 3:2 more rectangular.
However, the lens angle of view is not cropped on the horizontal view as the horizontal
top and bottom sides of the film/sensor plane remain the original size
and still touch the diameter of the circle.
The Phase One sensor is 53.7 x 40.4mm in size which is cropped on the
vertical 53.7mm sides down to 40.4mm within the 53.7mm x 53.7mm square
but maintains the same horizontal angle of view due to the 53.7mm
horizontal sides. Phase maintain that this is a Full Frame sensor
although the IQ180 sensor's horizontal sides are only 53.7mm. Phase crop
the vertical sides to create an almost square 4:3 aspect ratio image.
The 35mm 'Full Frame' sensor is 36mm x 24mm in size which is cropped on
the vertical 36mm sides down to 24mm within the 36mm x 36mm square but
maintains the same horizontal angle of view due to the 36mm horizontal sides.
35mm usually have the vertical sides cropped to create a rectangular 3:2
aspect ratio image.
The focal size of a lens is measured by the diagonal axis size measured
across a film or sensor (square) plane so a 56mm x 56mm plane for Medium
Format would measure 80mm and deliver an angle of view of approximately
46-53 degrees on a 80mm lens. In the case of a 35mm 'Full Frame' Format
film or sensor plane measuring 36mm x 36mm square would measure 50mm and
deliver an angle of view of 46-53 degrees approximately on a 50mm lens
but the depth of field would be shallower on the medium format 80mm lens
due to it's larger sensor size.
Side Note: A 35mm 'Full Frame' sensor is deemed to be cropped (APS-C) on
the horizontal angle of view when the 36mm horizontal side is shortened
to 23.6mm, typically a 1.5x sensor crop. A 50mm lens will then produce a
75mm horizontal 'field of view'.
I have put together a basic
diagram to help me understand the relationship between Medium Format + 35mm Full
Frame lenses.
Phase One
645DF Camera Body + Digital Backs - Specifications
The
Phase One digital backs are designed to work with a range of medium
format cameras and lenses that conform to the 'Open Platform' principal
for medium format technology. These include Mamiya, Hasselblad, Contax,
Alpa, Arca Swiss, Sinar, Linhof, Horseman, Cambo and Silvestri. There
are some older camera models that will not work with the Phase digital
backs.
Phase One - IQ180 Digital Back -
Image Quality
Like
other medium format systems that use a high pixel count with smaller
pixel pitch on their digital sensors,
Phase One, do not use AA
filters which assists resolving power but encourages moiré which can be
an issue for some photographers and depends a great deal on the type of
images they capture. Most
photographers are aware that as pixel pitch decreases, so does the chance
for moiré and usually pertaining to patterned materials, even facings on
buildings. However from the reviews I have read, Phase One handles the
moiré problem and keeps it under control.
All landscape photographers learn that stability is their friend for
crisp images captured at low ISO ratings. This new generation of sensors with their larger
number of pixels with reduced pixel pitch are the main cause of why camera and lens vibration are
your main problem especially on a windy day. The answer of course is a sturdy
and reasonably heavy tripod and very often weighted down by tying a
heavy backpack to its underside to pull it downwards and make it firmer
on the ground.
With it's ISO:35 'native setting' the IQ180 sensor captures images of
extra high quality with minimum processing. Just like in the old film
days, delivering stunning and beautifully coloured images.
At lower ISO ratings like
ISO:35, the
IQ180 sensor will certainly deliver the image
quality, especially for landscapes but I wonder if overall and at higher
ISO ratings will the camera perform as good? Phase have
Sensor+ technology which should address this and to a certain extent
provides the 'best of both worlds' the higher pixel count for the
low ISO:35 and the lower pixel count for the high ISO speed ratings.
Sensor+ pixel colour binning is revolutionary and the video below is
well worth viewing.
Long Exposures
The reviews cover 'long exposures, with the smaller P+ sensors delivering
noise free images shot with exposures as long as one hour but there are
no such claims as regards the sensors of the P +65 and
IQ140/160/180 digital backs. It has been reported that having ultra-long
exposure and Sensor+ technology in the same device was not possible at
this time? I guess the P 45+ digital back is the best of the Phase
'herd' for long exposure times of up to 1 hour but realistically how
many landscape photographers require that exposure time, unless you are
an Astro photographer.
IQ180 - Live View Because the IQ backs
use CCD sensors, as do the current P+ series, they are not capable of
fast-refresh Live View.
This quote from the Luminous Landscape Web site - "Finally, let's talk about the ugly: Because all Medium Format backs use
CCD sensors, when keeping the shutter open with light falling on the
sensor for a long period of time during Live View it is quite easy to
saturate the sensor. As a
consequence, the use of a strong neutral density filter will be required
when using Live View in bright light conditions. I call this ugly
because none of us wants to have to take any additional steps or carry
any additional equipment, but unfortunately, there is no way out of
this. Claus recommends the use of a variable neutral density filter in
the range of about 3-9 F/stops. I intend to carry just one filter of a
diameter large enough to cover all my lenses (either hand held in front
of the lens, or screwed on with an adapter ring)"
From the little on the Internet that I have read about IQ140/160/180 digital back
live view, it does look as if there is room for improvement but you know
that viewfinder and mirror is more than adequate for those very bright
days.
IQ180 -
Touch Screen
The
touch screen appears to offer excellent technology -
(3.2") 1.15 Megapixel retina style
touch screen (similar to that on the iPhone 4). It has 290 ppi, 16
million colors, and a 170º viewing angle.
The
screen has advanced touch controls, including zooming, swiping, and
similar touch screen controls. For those that don't care to use a touch
screen the IQ backs retain Phase One's intuitive four button controls.
My
Phase One System (Hypothetical) Choices + Costs
It is apparent that Phase One, is moving forward with
the Phase One 645DF camera, the IQ160 60Mp and the IQ180 80Mp digital
backs with their 'full frame' sensors, the new
Sensor+ technology and the
bundled Capture One 'RAW' converter software. There is the
possibility that new camera bodies will be released in 2012.
For landscape photography the IQ 180 digital back with it's 16bit
80Mpixel digital sensor and it's ISO:35
capability is my choice although the IQ 160 is also 'Full Frame' and an
excellent second choice.
The Phase One P 65+ digital back was also a consideration with it's
'full frame' sensor, especially as
it is the only P + model that has the new
Sensor+ technology
but it lacks 'Live View' and the touch controlled LCD screen.
It also has a smaller 2.2"
QVGA TFT screen with 230,000 pixels with high brightness and contrast,
both indoor and outdoors.
I like the the Schneider
Lenses because of their incredible build and they offer faster flash
sync with their leaf shutters but I also like the Phase One AF150 IF lens.
My logical lens choices, for landscapes from the Phase One web site would be in this purchase order
-
The Schneider
LS55 (34mm horizontal angle of view) f2.8 'Leaf Shutter' AF/Manual Lens
The
Phase One AF150 IF (93mm horizontal angle of view) f2.8 AF/Manual Lens
The
Schneider
LS80 (50mm horizontal angle of view) f2.8 'Leaf Shutter' AF/Manual Lens
I am not
really into wide landscapes, a Schneider LS55 f2.8 'Leaf Shutter'
AF/Manual Lens would be more than adequate for me. The Phase One AF150
IF f2.8 AF/Manual Lens
would be nice to bite into the landscape scene whilst the
the
Schneider
LS80 f2.8 'Leaf Shutter' AF/Manual Lens would be great
for general use. Moving away from Phase and Schneider, there are many
other excellent medium format lenses, new and second hand.
The Phase One AF150 IF (93mm FOV) f2.8 AF/Manual Lens would also be
excellent for portraits and 'wide open' f2.8 shots requiring a shallow
depth of field.
Most
suppliers in the UK offer a new Phase One System at reasonable discount
and also offer re-furbished 'factory re-built' digital backs.
These 'Brand New' and Re-furbished units are invariably offered as packages -
Phase
One 645DF Camera Body
A
Digital Back - P+ Series or IQ Series
A Schneider
LS80 f2.8 'Leaf Shutter' AF/Manual Lens
Capture
One 'RAW' Converter Software
Accessories
12
Months Warranty
Installation and a Days Training
The package prices vary
from around £6,795.00 re-furbished all
the way up to £34,000 Retail for a range topping IQ180 80Mp digital back
package. I have provided links to two UK Phase One Suppliers at the foot
of this section.
There is no doubt that Phase One have some awesome Medium Format
technology for capturing top quality and high resolution images,
especially landscapes and that is where it counts, due to the invariably
distant horizons requiring the best resolving digital sensors and
lenses.
I have always said that the Medium Format camera and lens marketplace
is up for grabs. It is inevitable that as photographers, even
non-professionals like myself, desire larger digital sensors above the
35mm 'Full Frame' of the Nikon and Canon DSLRs that Medium Format prices
will gradually fall to meet demand.
Pentax has already released a 645D DSLR 'Medium Format' 40Mpixel sensor
variant at a very reasonable price, what other camera manufacturers will follow.............time will tell!
I broke the Phase One System down into these component parts and each of
these areas is also demonstrated in video examples at the foot of this
page -
The
645DF Camera Body
Sensor +
The P+
Digital Backs
The IQ
Digital Backs
Schneider + Phase One Lenses
Capture
One Software
The Phase
One 645DF Digital Camera The focus system has
TTL phase-difference AF
with 3 focus points, Infrared AF assists for unfailing focus, Focus
confirmation in manual mode and Auto focus lock for swift AF/ M shift.
The light metering system has TTL metering (average, spot and auto),
Exposure compensation: +/- 5EV and a programmable AEL button. The flash
system uses the focal plane shutter up to 1/125sec and leaf shutter
lenses up to 1/1600sec with 1st and 2nd curtain flash synchronisation
with an X sync terminal and support for TTL flash.
The shutter is relatively fast for medium format at 1/4000secs to 60
minutes and up to 120 frames per minute. The viewfinder is a fixed prism
type with an exchangeable diopter from -5 to +3 and a LCD panel with
full exposure information and interchangeable focus screens with a laser
engraved mask for digital back.
The remote is a screw-in cable release on shutter button and a terminal
for electronic triggering devices. There are 3 custom dial modes for
capture settings, 36 custom settings and customizable dials and buttons.
The camera body uses 6 x AA batteries or a re-chargeable battery, it is
153x128x184mm in size and weighs 1,030g.
The camera body uses Phase One Digital focal plane lenses, Schneider
Kreuznach leaf shutter lenses, Mamiya 645 AFD lenses and is compatible
with Hasselblad V and Pentacon 6 lenses via a multimount adaptor. The
body is able to accept the open platform digital backs and the final
image resolution is determined by the digital back that is used!
Sensor +
Technology
The IQ180 digital
back features the patented Sensor+ technology, which is a highly
versatile tool that helps you capture beautiful images in a variety of
working conditions. You can choose to shoot in full resolution – up to
80 megapixel - or you can use the Sensor+ technology and go for a faster
workflow, capturing images with up to 20 megapixel resolution at 4 times
higher ISO speeds, up to ISO 3200.
The Sensor+ pixel colour binning is revolutionary and the video below is
well worth viewing.
Capturing in Sensor+ mode is especially well suited for shooting in low
light conditions and the technology enables you to capture sharper
images with less moiré. With Sensor+ there are no crop or lens factors;
you get the maximum wide angle performance with your lenses.
The P+
Digital Backs
The P 65+ digital
back features Sensor+ technology, a breakthrough innovation for unprecedented
versatility in photography.
The P 65+ has a 2.2" QVGA TFT screen with 230,000 pixels with high
brightness and contrast, both indoor and outdoors.
Choose 15 / 10 megapixel captures for faster workflow and higher
sensitivity or 60.5 / 40 megapixel captures for extreme details. By
adding pixels together on the CCD chip, larger pixels are created for
increased sensitivity and smaller files. Sensor+ is unique by
maintaining full sensor area and image quality while scaling.
P 45+ and P 30+ feature exclusive Phase One XPose+
technology. XPose+ enables noise free exposures up to one hour,
unlocking a world of creative options. The P 65+ does not have that
option.
The P 65+
digital back delivers a 34mm 'field of view' with a 55mm lens
Capture One
software package is a
professional RAW converter
and is included with a digital back
The IQ
Digital Backs
The Phase One IQ180/160/140
series digital backs offers 80, 60.5 and 40 megapixels resolution
respectively. IQ180 and IQ160 both capture in full-frame 645 format.
With these backs you can capture images of stunning quality with extreme
detail reproduction. The high resolution gives you maximum versatility
with your images, ensuring high quality and usage, even when you work
with cropped images. The full-frame capture format ensures the best wide
angle performance with your lenses.
The IQ180 features a
large 3.2" high resolution touch display to zoom, pan and browse
images. With the 1.15 megapixel resolution display very fine details
can be checked instantly. With a very high pixel pitch of 290 ppi
(dpi) most people can't distinguish between the individual pixels at
a normal viewing distance. The automatic adjustment of brightness
and contrast ensures that the display is visible in various light
scenarios. The display also has an extreme viewing angle of 170
degrees, so images easily can be validated at a glance. It has
extremely good color rendition and color gradations with 16 million
colors.
Live View albeit
with a slow refresh rate.
Fastest tethered
capture - With the IQ180 you are sure to have consistent fast
capture rates when photographing. The digital back features a
FireWire 800 connection, ensuring the fastest tethered capture
speeds possible today. A new optimized hardware feature is the
integrated battery charger which charges the battery
from the FireWire 800 connection. This ensures that the battery is
charged when you’re shooting tethered, and your back is always ready
for untethered use offering you more versatility in your creative
work.
Sensor+ technology for
faster workflow and higher ISO sensitivity
Focus Mask to validate
depth-of-field and image focus. When Focus Mask is turned on,
the IQ180 automatically displays a colored semi-transparent mask on
top of the preview to show which parts of the image are in focus.
It's extremely useful to validate depth-of-field and get instant
feedback about whether a shot is perfectly focused or not.
12.5 f-stops dynamic
range.
The IQ180 has memory
card interface capable of moving data faster than any current memory
cards can deliver. In practice this means that with the fastest
CompactFlash cards you can continue to capture images until your
card is full without experiencing any slowdown in performance.
The IQ180 has vertical
and horizontal capture guidance available to help you align your
shots perfectly. Like a virtual horizon in an aircraft, it measures
the roll and pitch of the camera, and in Capture One the data from
the tool can be used to rotate or perform keystone correction.
Entirely built of 100%
machined aircraft grade aluminum for highest quality black chrome
finish. Stronger than any other digital back. Black Anodizing
surface and LCD cover glass are extremely scratch resistant. All
electronic connectors and ports are protected with automatic
retracting hatches or rubber covers.
This IQ180
digital back delivers a 34mm 'field of view' with a 55mm lens.
Capture One
software package is a
professional RAW
converter and is included with a digital back.
Capture One
Software
Capture One has been
optimized for shooting with Phase One digital backs. Together with the digital
back this professional RAW converter and image editing software deliver the
world’s highest image quality with excellent color and detail. It contains all
the essential tools and high-end performance in one package to enable you to
capture, organize, edit, share and print images in a fast, flexible and
efficient workflow.